Comparing the Sony Alpha a55 Kit Lens to the Tamron 17-50 f/2.8 Zoom


The Sony Alpha a55 is available with a reasonably nice kit lens: the Sony 18-55 f/3.5. I bought this with my a55, but also bought a Tamron 17-50 f/2.8 zoom.
To me, the Tamron seemed like a good investment just to get those extra stops of brightness. But how do these two lenses compare in image quality?

First Test Scene


For the first test scene, I used both lenses zoomed to their 35mm position, manual focus, aperture priority, 200 ISO, and shot frames at f/8, f/4.5 (the widest available on the Sony), and f/2.8 (only available on the Tamron.)
The red box indicates the crop region of the shot shown at 1:1 scale in the table below. No images in these tables have received any post-processing, other than bringing camera-original .jpg files into Photoshop to crop them.

At f/8, both lenses looked good overall. There was a bit more CA (purple fringing) on high-contrast edges near the edge of frame with the Sony. Both lenses got softer (especially at the sides) at f/4.5. When the Tamron was opened to f/2.8 it got even softer, but still produced a respectable image.

Sony 18-55 f/3.5 Kit Lens
Tamron 17-50 f/2.8 Zoom

35mm f/8

35mm f/8

35mm f/4.5

35mm f/4.5
N/A on Kit Lens.

35mm f/2.8
Full-res original files from the camera (warning: this may be slow.)
Sony 18-55 f/3.5 Kit Lens:
f/22 f/16 f/8 f/4.5
Tamron 17-50 f/2.8 Zoom:
f/22 f/16 f/8 f/4.5 f/2.8

Second Test


For the next scene I zoomed both lenses all the way out. This put the Kit Lens at 18mm, and the Tamron at 17mm. I know it's a bit unfair to compare them at different focal lengths, but the focal lengths are similar, and this shows how they both work zoomed all the way out. I shot all images at f/3.5 (the widest that the Sony lens would open.) The two red boxes show the two areas that are shown in the table below.

When zoomed out to 17mm, the outer edges of the Tamron showed more CA (the top crop region shows the worst CA I saw from the Tamron.) The Sony showed less CA, although it had a little barrel distortion (the lamppost in the lower left corner looks a bit curved in the Sony at 18mm.) Even though these are 1:1 crops from 16MP images, I see the most pronounced difference between the lenses at their widest zooms with wider apertures.

Sony 18-55 f/3.5 Kit Lens Tamron 17-50 f/2.8 Zoom

18mm f/3.5

17mm f/3.5

18mm f/3.5

17mm f/3.5

Full-res original files from the camera (warning: this may be slow.)
Sony 18-55 f/3.5 Kit Lens:
f/22 f/16 f/8 f/3.5
Tamron 17-50 f/2.8 Zoom:
f/22 f/16 f/8 f/3.5 f/2.8

Third Test


For the third test, I again had the Sony Kit Lens zoomed all the way out to 18mm, and the Tamron zoomed all the way out to 17mm. I opened the Tamron up to f/2.8 as well. As with last time, I chose crop-regions near the wide sides of the frame where I saw some distortion and CA. I know this is un-fair, but (to me at least) it's interesting to compare the lenses when they are both zoomed all the way out, and both opened to their widest aperture, even if they have different apertures and slightly different focal lengths. The red boxes indicate the crop areas that appear in the table below.

Sony 18-55 f/3.5 Kit Lens Tamron 17-50 f/2.8 Zoom

18mm f/3.5

17mm f/2.8

18mm f/3.5

17mm f/2.8

Full-res original files from the camera (warning: this may be slow.)
Sony 18-55 f/3.5 Kit Lens:
18mm Zoom, f/3.5
35mm Zoom, f/4.5
55mm Zoom, f/5.6
18mm Zoom, f/16
35mm Zoom, f/16
55mm Zoom, f/16
Tamron 17-50 f/2.8 Zoom:
17mm Zoom, f/2.8
35mm Zoom, f/2.8
50mm Zoom, f/2.8
17mm Zoom, f/16
35mm Zoom, f/16
50mm Zoom, f/16


Copyright © 2011 by Jeremy Birn, www.3dRender.com.